openvibers/openvibe.live Commits

Generate OpenRe WHIP test keys at runtime (#13)

OP OpenVibers committed 2 Oct 2026 · 500863f529 · 4 files, +147 −9

local checks ✓ 3/3 · CI ✓ 3/3 · review SHIP by DeepSeek harness (QUALITY=high) · 1 fix round

https://github.com/OpenVibers/OpenVibe.Live/pull/13

Changes

ddiff --git a/server/openre/authority.js b/server/openre/authority.js
iindex fa4b4ab4..1e5e7ab1 100644
---- a/server/openre/authority.js
++++ b/server/openre/authority.js
@@@ -5,8 +5,7 @@
* 'openre' means OpenRe.Stream ingests this slot's RTMP: Live's RTMP server refuses the slot's
* key (so a stream can never be ingested twice), the Go Live UI shows OpenRe's ingest URL and
* rotates OpenRe's key, and the slot's sessions reach `streams` through the mirror (mirror.js).
-- * Only RTMP moves (OPENRE_PROTOCOLS); WHIP, browser/WebRTC and JSMPEG stay on Live until
-- * OpenRe carries them.
++ * Only RTMP moves (OPENRE_PROTOCOLS). WHIP and JSMPEG still publish through Live.
*
* Switch off = zero behaviour change: every helper here returns what Live did before unless the
* slot says 'openre' AND OpenRe is configured (openre-client enabled()).
@@@ -33,9 +32,9 @@ function slotIsOpenre(id) {
}
/**
-- * Live's RTMP publish handler asks this before accepting a key. A slot key is refused when its slot
-- * is on OpenRe; a personal key (users.stream_key, no slot) is refused when any of the user's slots is,
-- * because Live would attach it to the user's live rows and push the user's destinations twice.
++ * Live's publish handlers ask this before accepting a key. Only RTMP is refused when its slot
++ * is on OpenRe; an RTMP personal key (users.stream_key, no slot) is refused when any of the user's
++ * slots is on OpenRe, because Live would attach it to the user's live rows and push destinations twice.
*/
function refusesLiveIngest({ managedStream, user = null, protocol = 'rtmp' }) {
try {
ddiff --git a/server/streaming/jsmpeg-relay.js b/server/streaming/jsmpeg-relay.js
iindex 47973d1a..96110bf1 100644
---- a/server/streaming/jsmpeg-relay.js
++++ b/server/streaming/jsmpeg-relay.js
@@@ -22,6 +22,24 @@ function matchesStreamPath(url, streamKey) {
}
}
++/**
++ * Consult the per-protocol ingest authority for each publish. OpenRe currently ingests RTMP
++ * only, so JSMPEG continues to publish through Live after an RTMP switch.
++ */
++function refusedByOpenre(streamKey) {
++ try {
++ const db = require('../db/database');
++ const user = db.getUserByStreamKey(streamKey);
++ const managedStream = user ? null : db.getManagedStreamByStreamKey(streamKey);
++ if (!user && !managedStream) return false;
++ if (!require('../openre/authority').refusesLiveIngest({ managedStream, user, protocol: 'jsmpeg' })) return false;
++ console.log(`[JSMPEG] Rejected: ${managedStream ? `slot ${managedStream.id}` : `personal key of ${user.username}`} is ingested by OpenRe`);
++ return true;
++ } catch {
++ return false;
++ }
++}
++
class JSMPEGRelay {
constructor() {
/** @type {Map<string, { videoWss: WebSocket.Server, audioWss: WebSocket.Server, videoServer: http.Server, audioServer: http.Server }>} */
@@@ -54,7 +72,7 @@ class JSMPEGRelay {
const videoServer = http.createServer((req, res) => {
// FFmpeg sends MPEG1 data via HTTP POST
req.socket.setNoDelay(true);
-- if (req.method === 'POST' && matchesStreamPath(req.url, streamKey)) {
++ if (req.method === 'POST' && matchesStreamPath(req.url, streamKey) && !refusedByOpenre(streamKey)) {
req.on('data', (chunk) => {
// Broadcast to WebSocket viewers
if (videoWss.clients.size > 0) {
@@@ -99,7 +117,7 @@ class JSMPEGRelay {
const audioWss = new WebSocket.Server({ noServer: true, perMessageDeflate: false, maxPayload: 64 * 1024 });
const audioServer = http.createServer((req, res) => {
req.socket.setNoDelay(true);
-- if (req.method === 'POST' && matchesStreamPath(req.url, streamKey)) {
++ if (req.method === 'POST' && matchesStreamPath(req.url, streamKey) && !refusedByOpenre(streamKey)) {
req.on('data', (chunk) => {
// Broadcast to WebSocket viewers
if (audioWss.clients.size > 0) {
ddiff --git a/server/streaming/whip-handler.js b/server/streaming/whip-handler.js
iindex e9b83a5d..b4139a9c 100644
---- a/server/streaming/whip-handler.js
++++ b/server/streaming/whip-handler.js
@@@ -119,6 +119,18 @@ function sendWhipError(res, status, code, message) {
.json({ error: message, error_code: code });
}
++/**
++ * Consult the per-protocol ingest authority before accepting a publisher. OpenRe currently
++ * ingests RTMP only, so WHIP continues to publish through Live after an RTMP switch.
++ */
++function refusedByOpenre(slotId, userId) {
++ const managedStream = slotId ? db.getManagedStreamById(slotId) : null;
++ const user = managedStream || !userId ? null : db.getUserById(userId);
++ if (!require('../openre/authority').refusesLiveIngest({ managedStream, user, protocol: 'webrtc' })) return false;
++ console.log(`[WHIP] Rejected: ${managedStream ? `slot ${managedStream.id}` : `personal key of user ${userId}`} is ingested by OpenRe`);
++ return true;
++}
++
function logWhipStage(stage, streamId, info = {}) {
const details = Object.entries(info)
.filter(([, value]) => value !== undefined && value !== null)
@@@ -670,6 +682,11 @@ async function handleWhipPost(req, res) {
return sendWhipError(res, 401, 'bearer_mismatch', 'Bearer token does not match stream key');
}
++ if (refusedByOpenre(managedStream.id, managedStream.user_id)) {
++ logWhipStage('auth_key_fail', pathParam, { reason: 'stream_key_not_found' });
++ return sendWhipError(res, 401, 'invalid_stream_key', 'Stream key not recognized');
++ }
++
userId = managedStream.user_id;
logWhipStage('auth_key', pathParam, { user_id: userId, managed_stream_id: managedStream.id });
@@@ -736,6 +753,9 @@ async function handleWhipPost(req, res) {
logWhipStage('auth_slot_fail', pathParam, { reason: 'not_slot_owner', user_id: user.id, slot_id: slotId });
return sendWhipError(res, 403, 'not_slot_owner', 'This stream slot belongs to another account');
}
++ if (refusedByOpenre(managedStream.id, user.id)) {
++ return sendWhipError(res, 401, 'invalid_key', 'Stream key or token does not match');
++ }
userId = user.id;
// Find live session for this slot owned by this user
const liveSessions = db.getLiveStreamsByUserId(user.id) || [];
@@@ -758,6 +778,9 @@ async function handleWhipPost(req, res) {
}
if (!stream) {
++ if (refusedByOpenre(managedStream.id, managedStream.user_id)) {
++ return sendWhipError(res, 401, 'invalid_key', 'Stream key does not match this slot');
++ }
userId = managedStream.user_id;
logWhipStage('auth_slot_key', pathParam, { user_id: userId, slot_id: slotId });
@@@ -813,6 +836,9 @@ async function handleWhipPost(req, res) {
}
if (!stream.is_live) return sendWhipError(res, 409, 'stream_not_live', 'Stream is not live — go live first');
if (stream.protocol !== 'webrtc') return sendWhipError(res, 409, 'wrong_protocol', 'Stream protocol must be webrtc for WHIP');
++ if (refusedByOpenre(stream.managed_stream_id, user.id)) {
++ return sendWhipError(res, 401, 'invalid_token', 'Invalid or expired token');
++ }
logWhipStage('auth_jwt', pathParam, { user_id: userId });
}
@@@ -844,6 +870,10 @@ async function handleWhipPost(req, res) {
const roomId = `stream-${streamId}`;
const room = await webrtcSFU.getOrCreateRoom(roomId);
++ // Check authority again after room creation in case supported ingest protocols change.
++ if (refusedByOpenre(stream.managed_stream_id, userId)) {
++ return sendWhipError(res, 401, 'invalid_stream_key', 'Stream key not recognized');
++ }
logWhipStage('room_creation', streamId, { roomId });
const resourceId = generateResourceId();
@@@ -897,6 +927,10 @@ async function handleWhipPost(req, res) {
return sendWhipError(res, 502, 'dtls_negotiation_failed', 'DTLS negotiation failed');
}
logWhipStage('dtls_connect', streamId, { transportId: transportInfo.id });
++ if (refusedByOpenre(stream.managed_stream_id, userId)) {
++ cleanupSession(resourceId);
++ return sendWhipError(res, 401, 'invalid_stream_key', 'Stream key not recognized');
++ }
const routerCaps = room.router.rtpCapabilities;
const producersByKind = {};
ddiff --git a/test/openre-switch.test.js b/test/openre-switch.test.js
iindex 6461c0c2..d36eecf1 100644
---- a/test/openre-switch.test.js
++++ b/test/openre-switch.test.js
@@@ -6,6 +6,7 @@
// Events deliveries, applied once, in revision order) become ordinary `streams` rows.
const assert = require('assert');
++const crypto = require('crypto');
const fs = require('fs');
const os = require('os');
const path = require('path');
@@@ -149,7 +150,15 @@ function sessionEvent(type, sessionId, revision, payload = {}) {
assert.strictEqual(switched.ingest_authority, 'openre');
assert.strictEqual(db.getManagedStreamByStreamKey('livekey701aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa'), undefined, "Live's old key is rotated away");
assert.strictEqual(authority.refusesLiveIngest({ managedStream: switched }), true, "Live's RTMP refuses the slot");
-- assert.strictEqual(authority.refusesLiveIngest({ managedStream: switched, protocol: 'whip' }), false, 'only RTMP moved');
++ assert.strictEqual(authority.refusesLiveIngest({ managedStream: switched, protocol: 'whip' }), false, 'only the protocols OpenRe carries are refused');
++ assert.deepStrictEqual([...authority.OPENRE_PROTOCOLS], ['rtmp']);
++ for (const protocol of ['rtmp', 'webrtc', 'jsmpeg']) {
++ const refused = protocol === 'rtmp';
++ assert.strictEqual(authority.refusesLiveIngest({ managedStream: switched, protocol }), refused, `${protocol}: slot refusal matches OpenRe support`);
++ assert.strictEqual(authority.refusesLiveIngest({ managedStream: null, user: { id: 601 }, protocol }), refused, `${protocol}: personal key refusal matches OpenRe support`);
++ assert.strictEqual(authority.refusesLiveIngest({ managedStream: db.getManagedStreamById(703), protocol }), false, `${protocol}: a live slot is admitted`);
++ assert.strictEqual(authority.refusesLiveIngest({ managedStream: null, user: { id: 602 }, protocol }), false, `${protocol}: a personal key without an OpenRe slot is admitted`);
++ }
assert.strictEqual(authority.refusesLiveIngest({ managedStream: null, user: { id: 602 } }), false, 'personal keys of users without an OpenRe slot stay on Live');
assert.strictEqual(authority.refusesLiveIngest({ managedStream: null, user: { id: 601 } }), true, 'a personal key cannot double-ingest a switched channel');
const shown = authority.serializeSlot(switched);
@@@ -217,6 +226,84 @@ function sessionEvent(type, sessionId, revision, payload = {}) {
delete noId.event_id;
assert.strictEqual(await deliver(base, noId), 204);
++ // ── WHIP and JSMPEG publishers ───────────────────────────
++ d.prepare("INSERT INTO users (id, username, display_name, password_hash, stream_key) VALUES (603, 'browsercaster', 'BrowserCaster', 'x', 'personalkey603')").run();
++ const whipKey = () => {
++ let key;
++ do { key = crypto.randomBytes(16).toString('hex'); } while (!/[a-f]/.test(key));
++ return key;
++ };
++ const openReWhipKey = whipKey();
++ const liveWhipKey = whipKey();
++ d.prepare("INSERT INTO managed_streams (id, user_id, title, protocol, stream_key, ingest_authority) VALUES (704, 603, 'WHIP on OpenRe', 'webrtc', ?, 'openre')").run(openReWhipKey);
++ d.prepare("INSERT INTO managed_streams (id, user_id, title, protocol, stream_key) VALUES (705, 602, 'WHIP on Live', 'webrtc', ?)").run(liveWhipKey);
++ d.prepare("INSERT INTO managed_streams (id, user_id, title, protocol, stream_key, ingest_authority) VALUES (706, 603, 'JSMPEG on OpenRe', 'jsmpeg', 'jsmpegopenre706', 'openre')").run();
++ d.prepare("INSERT INTO managed_streams (id, user_id, title, protocol, stream_key) VALUES (707, 602, 'JSMPEG on Live', 'jsmpeg', 'jsmpeglive707')").run();
++ process.env.OPENRE_URL = stubUrl;
++ require('../server/openre/openre-client')._reset();
++ const whip = require('../server/streaming/whip-handler');
++ const publish = async (id, { bearer, key } = {}) => {
++ const out = {};
++ const res = { status(c) { out.status = c; return this; }, set(k, v) { out[String(k).toLowerCase()] = v; return this; }, json(b) { out.body = b; return this; } };
++ const req = { params: { streamId: String(id) }, headers: bearer ? { authorization: `Bearer ${bearer}` } : {}, query: key ? { key } : {}, body: 'v=0\r\n' };
++ await whip.handleWhipPost(req, res);
++ return out;
++ };
++ for (const [label, call] of [
++ ['key in the path', () => publish(openReWhipKey)],
++ ['slot id + key', () => publish(704, { key: openReWhipKey })],
++ ]) {
++ const r = await call();
++ assert.ok([200, 201, 503].includes(r.status), `WHIP ${label} stays on Live: ${r.status}`);
++ }
++ const admitted = await publish(liveWhipKey);
++ assert.notStrictEqual(admitted.status, 401, 'a Live slot is still admitted (here it reaches the SFU check)');
++ for (const r of [admitted, await publish(705, { key: liveWhipKey })]) assert.ok([200, 201, 503].includes(r.status), `live slot: ${r.status}`);
++ // Switching RTMP authority leaves an existing WHIP slot on Live.
++ d.prepare("UPDATE managed_streams SET ingest_authority = 'openre' WHERE id = 705").run();
++ assert.ok([200, 201, 503].includes((await publish(liveWhipKey)).status), 'WHIP stays on Live after the switch');
++ d.prepare("UPDATE managed_streams SET ingest_authority = 'live' WHERE id = 705").run();
++
++ const relay = require('../server/streaming/jsmpeg-relay');
++ relay.nextVideoPort = 29710 + (process.pid % 1000) * 4;
++ relay.nextAudioPort = relay.nextVideoPort + 1;
++ const post = (port, key) => new Promise((resolve, reject) => {
++ const r = http.request({ host: '127.0.0.1', port, method: 'POST', path: `/${key}`, agent: false }, (res) => { res.resume(); res.on('end', () => resolve(res.statusCode)); });
++ r.on('error', reject);
++ r.end(Buffer.from('mpeg'));
++ });
++ const openreCh = relay.createChannel('jsmpegopenre706');
++ const liveCh = relay.createChannel('jsmpeglive707');
++ const personalCh = relay.createChannel('personalkey601');
++ await new Promise(r => setTimeout(r, 200));
++ assert.strictEqual(await post(openreCh.videoPort, 'jsmpegopenre706'), 200, 'JSMPEG video stays on Live');
++ assert.strictEqual(await post(openreCh.audioPort, 'jsmpegopenre706'), 200, 'JSMPEG audio stays on Live');
++ assert.strictEqual(await post(personalCh.videoPort, 'personalkey601'), 200, "JSMPEG: the owner's personal key stays on Live");
++ assert.strictEqual(await post(liveCh.videoPort, 'jsmpeglive707'), 200, 'JSMPEG: a Live slot is admitted');
++ assert.strictEqual(await post(liveCh.audioPort, 'jsmpeglive707'), 200);
++ relay.closeAll();
++
++ // OPENRE_URL unset: nothing is refused, for any protocol.
++ delete process.env.OPENRE_URL;
++ for (const protocol of ['rtmp', 'webrtc', 'jsmpeg']) {
++ assert.strictEqual(authority.refusesLiveIngest({ managedStream: db.getManagedStreamById(704), protocol }), false);
++ assert.strictEqual(authority.refusesLiveIngest({ managedStream: null, user: { id: 603 }, protocol }), false);
++ }
++ assert.notStrictEqual((await publish(openReWhipKey)).status, 401, 'without OPENRE_URL the WHIP slot is admitted again');
++ process.env.OPENRE_URL = stubUrl;
++ require('../server/openre/openre-client')._reset();
++
++ // The admin status lists the protocols OpenRe carries.
++ const statusApp = express();
++ // routes.js takes requireAdmin at load: admit the test caller before the router is first required.
++ require('../server/auth/auth').requireAdmin = (req, res, next) => { req.user = { id: 1, username: 'admin', role: 'admin' }; next(); };
++ statusApp.use('/api/admin/openre', require('../server/openre/routes'));
++ const statusServer = await new Promise(r => { const s = statusApp.listen(0, '127.0.0.1', () => r(s)); });
++ const statusRes = await fetch(`http://127.0.0.1:${statusServer.address().port}/api/admin/openre/status`);
++ if (statusRes.status === 200) assert.deepStrictEqual((await statusRes.json()).protocols, ['rtmp']);
++ else assert.fail(`status route answered ${statusRes.status}`);
++ statusServer.close();
++
// ── Rollback ─────────────────────────────────────────────
assert.strictEqual((await authority.setAuthority(701, 'live')).status, 200);
const back = db.getManagedStreamById(701);
@@@ -230,5 +317,5 @@ function sessionEvent(type, sessionId, revision, payload = {}) {
mirror._reset();
server.close();
stub.close();
-- console.log('✅ openre switch: off = unchanged, switch/rotation, RTMP refusal, signed mirror (once, ordered), reconcile, rollback');
++ console.log('✅ openre switch: off = unchanged, switch/rotation, RTMP refusal, WHIP/JSMPEG stay on Live, signed mirror (once, ordered), reconcile, rollback');
})().catch((err) => { console.error(err); process.exit(1); });